AtthaPali Vol.29

12. Culabyuhasuttavannana [885-6] Sakam sakam ditthiparibbasanati culabyuhasuttam. Ka uppatti? idampi tasmimyeva mahasamaye "sabbepime ditthigatika `sadhurupamha'ti bhananti, kim nu kho sadhurupavime attanoyeva ditthiya patitthahanti, udahu annampi ditthim ganhanti"ti uppannacittanam ekaccanam devatanam tamattham pakasetum purimanayeneva nimmitabuddhena attanam pucchapetva vuttam. Tattha adito dvepi gatha pucchagathayeva. Tasu sakam sakam ditthiparibbasanati attano attano ditthiya vasamana. Viggayha nana kusala vadantiti ditthibalavaggaham gahetva, tattha "kusalamha"ti patijanamana puthu puthu vadanti, @Footnote: ¹ cha.Ma.,i. nissaye ca natva Ekam na vadanti. Yo evam janati sa vedi dhammam, idam patikkosamakevali soti tanca ditthim sandhaya yo evam janati, so dhammam vedi. ^1- Idam pana patikkosanto hino hotiti vadanti. Baloti hino. Akkusaloti avidva. [887-8] Idani tisso vissajjagatha honti. Ta purimaddhena vuttamattham pacchimaddhena patibyuhetva thita. Tena byuhena uttarasuttato ca appakatta idam suttam "culabyuhan"ti namam labhi. ^2- Tattha parassa ce dhammanti parassa ditthim. Sabbeva ^3- balati evam sante sabbe ime bala hontiti adhippayo. Kimkaranam? sabbevime ditthiparibbasanati, sanditthiya ceva na vivadata. Samsuddhapanna kusala mutimati sakaya ditthiya na vivadata na vodata sankilitthava samana samsuddhapanna ca kusala ca suddhapanna ca kusala ca mutimanto ca te honti ce. Atha va "sanditthiya ce pana vivadata"tipi patho. Tassattho:- sakaya pana ditthiya vodata samsuddhapanna kusala mutimanto honti ce. Na tesam kociti evam sante tesam ekopi nihinapanno ^4- na hoti. Kimkaranam? ditthi hi tesampi tatha samatta, yatha itaresanti. [889] Na vahametanti gathaya sankhepattho ^5- :- yam te mithu dve dve jana annamannam "bala"ti ahu, aham etam tathiyam tacchanti ^6- va neva brumi. Kimkaranam? yasma sabbe te sakam sakam ditthim "idameva saccam moghamannan"ti akamsu. Tena ca karanena param "balo"ti dahanti. Ettha ca "tathiyan"ti "kathivan"ti dvepi patha. ^7- [890] Yamahuti pucchagathaya yam ditthisaccam tathiyanti ^8- eke aha. @Footnote: ¹ ka. vedayati ² cha.Ma. labhati ³ ka. sabbevime @⁴ cha.Ma. hinapanno ⁵ ka. sambandho ⁶ ka. tathivanti taccham @⁷ ka. dvidhapi patho ⁸ ka. yanti ditthisaccam tathivanti [891] Ekam hi saccanti vissajjanagathaya ekam saccam nirodho maggo va. Yasmim paja no vivade pajananti yamhi sacce pajananto paja no vivadeyya. Sayam thunantiti attana vadanti. [892] Kasma nuti pucchagathaya pavadiyaseti vadino. Udahu te takkamanussarantiti te vadino udahu attano takkamattam anugacchanti. [893] Nahevati vissajjanagathaya annatra sannaya niccaniti thapetva sannamattena niccanti gahitaggahanani. Takkanca ditthisu pakappayitvati attano micchasankappamattam ditthisu janetva. Yasma pana ditthisu vitakkam janenta ditthiyopi janenti, tasma niddese ^1- vuttam "ditthigatani janenti sanjanenti"tiadi. [894-5] Idani evam nanasaccesu asantesu takkamattamanussarantanam ditthigatikanam vippatipattim dassetum "ditthe sutetiadika gathayo abhasi. Tattha dittheti dittham, ditthasuddhinti ^2- adhippayo. Esa nayo sutadisu. Ete ca nissaya vimanadassiti ete ditthidhamme nissayitva suddhibhavasankhatam vimanam asammanam passantopi. Vinicchaye thatva pahassamano, balo paro akkusaloti cahati evam vimanadassipi tasmim ditthivinicchaye thatva tutthijato hasajato hutva "paro hino ca avidva ca"ti evam vadatiyeva. Evam sante yenevati gatha. Tattha sayamattanati sayameva attanam. Vimanetiti garahati. Tadeva pavati tadeva vacanam ditthim vadati, tam va puggalam. [896] Atisaraditthiyati gathayattho:- so evam taya lakkhanatisariniya atisaraditthiya samatto punno uddhumato, tena ca ditthimanena samatto @Footnote: ¹ khu.maha. 29/562/355 (sya) ² ka. ditthisuddhiti "paripunno aham kevali"ti evam paripunnamani sayameva attanam manasa "aham pandito"ti abhisincati. Kimkaranam? ditthi hi sa tassa tatha samattati. [897] Parassa ceti gathaya sambandho attho ca:- kinca bhiyyo? yo so vinicchaye thatva pahassamano "balo paro akkusalo"ti caha, tassa parassa ce hi vacasa so tena vuccamano nihino hoti, tumo saha hoti nihinapanno, sopi teneva saha nihinapanno hoti. Sopi hi nam ^1- "balo"ti vadati. Athassa vacanam appamanam, so pana sayameva vedagu ca dhiro ca hoti. Evam sante na koci balo samanesu atthi. Sabbepi hi te attano icchaya pandita. [898] Annam itoti gatha sambandho attho ca:- "atha ce sayam vedagu hoti dhiro, na koci balo samanesu atthi"ti evam hi vuttepi siya kissaci "kasma"ti. Tattha vuccate:- yasma annam ito yabhivadanti dhammam aparaddha suddhimakevali te, evampi titthya puthuso vadanti, ye ito annam ditthim abhivadanti, ye aparaddha viraddha suddhimaggam, akevalino ca teti evam puthutitthiya yasma vadantiti vuttam hoti. Kasma panevam vadantiti ce? sanditthiragena hi tayabhiratta, ^2- yasma sakena ditthiragena abhirattati vuttam hoti. [899-900] Evam abhiratta ca:- idheva suddhinti gatha. Tattha sakayaneti sakamagge. Dalham vadanati dalhavada. Evanca dalhavadesu tesu yo koci titthiyo sakayena vapi dalham vadano kamettha baloti param daheyya, sankhepato tattha sassatucchedasankhate vittharato va @Footnote: ¹ ka. nihinam ² cha.Ma.,i. tebhiratta Natthikaissarakarananiyatadibhede sake ayatane "idameva saccan"ti dalham vadano kam param ettha ditthigate "balo"ti saha dhammena passeyya, nanu sabbopi tassa matena pandito eva supatipanno eva ca. Evam sante ca sayameva so medhagamavaheyya ^1- param vadam balamasuddhidhammam, ^2- sopi param "balo ca asuddhidhammo ca ayan"ti vadanto attanova kalaham avaheyya. Kasma? yasma sabbopi tassa matena pandito eva supatipannoyeva ca. [901] Evam sabbathapi vinicchaye thatva sayam pamaya uddham sa ^3- lokasmim vivadameti, ditthiyam thatva sayanca sattharadini nimminitva so bhiyyo vivadametiti. Evam pana vinicchayesu adinavam natva ariyamaggena hitvana sabbani vinicchayani na medhagam kurute ^4- jantu loketi arahattanikutena desanam nitthapesi. Desanapariyosane purabhedasutte vuttasadisoyevabhisamayo ahositi. Paramatthajotikaya khuddakatthakathaya suttanipatatthakathaya culabyuhasuttavannana nitthita. ---------------------

The Pali Atthakatha in Roman Book 29 page 395-399. http://84000.org/tipitaka/atthapali/read_rm.php?B=29&A=8894&modeTY=2 อรรถกถาบาลีอักษรไทย :- http://84000.org/tipitaka/atthapali/read_th.php?B=29&A=8894&modeTY=2 อ่านอรรถกถาแปลไทย :- http://84000.org/tipitaka/attha/attha.php?b=25&i=419 เนื้อความพระไตรปิฎกฉบับหลวง :- http://84000.org/tipitaka/read/r.php?B=25&A=10418 พระไตรปิฎกฉบับบาลีอักษรไทย :- http://84000.org/tipitaka/read/pali_read.php?B=25&A=10500 The Pali Tipitaka in Roman Character :- http://84000.org/tipitaka/read/roman_read.php?B=25&A=10500 Contents of The Tipitaka Volume 25 http://84000.org/tipitaka/read/?index_25