AtthaPali Vol.55

19. Pativedhanuyogadivannana [217] Bhavam nissaya panhe bhavanti upapattibhavam. [218] Vedanam vediyamanapanhe vedanam vediyamano pariggahitavedano yogavacarova pajanati, balaputhujjano nappajanati. @Footnote: ¹ cha.Ma......adisuttavasena ² sam.sa. 15/171/163

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page158.

[224] Kayanupassanadipanho ^1- uttanatthoyeva. ^2- [226] Parayanakathaya ^3- sunnato lokam avekkhassuti sattasunnatavasena khandhalokam olokehiti attho. [228] Puggalo avekkhatiti sakavadipuccha. Paravadissa hi "sunnato lokam avekkhassu"ti gathaya yo avekkhati, so puggaloti laddhi, tasma nam evam pucchati. Saha rupenati rupakayena saddhim, tato anissito ^4- hutvati attho. Idam pancavokaravasena anujanitva puna tam jivanti puttho suttavirodhabhayeneva patikkhipati. Vina rupenati idam catuvokaravasena anujanitva puna annam jivanti puttho suttavirodhabhayeneva patikkhipati. "abbhantaragato"ti ca "bahiddha nikkhamitva"ti ca idam "saha rupena vina rupena"ti hettha vuttassa lakkhanavacanam. Tattha abbhantaragatoti rupassa antogato, ito va eto va ^5- anikkhamitva rupaparicchedavaseneva thapito ^6- hutvati attho. Nikkhamitvati rupaparicchedam atikkamitva, rupam anissito hutvati attho. [231] Anattati attana jivena puggalena rahito, ekadhammepi puggalo natthiti attho. Evam sabbasuttanam agamatthakathasu vuttanayeneva attho veditabbo. Idam ^7- pana sandhaya bhasitamattameva vakkhama. [237] Vuttam bhagavata sappikumbhotiadi "sabbava desana yathavutta- vaseneva ^8- atthato na gahetabba"ti dassanattham abhatam. Yatha hi suvannam gahetva kato suvannavikaro kumbho suvannakumbhoti vuccati, na evam sappim gahetva kato sappissa vikaro sappikumbho nama atthi. Yasmim pana kumbhe pakkhittam, so sappikumbho namati ayamettha attho. Telakumbhadisupi eseva @Footnote: ¹ cha.Ma......panha ² cha.Ma. uttanatthayeva ³ cha.Ma. parayanagathaya @⁴ cha.Ma. anissato ⁵ cha.Ma. etto va ⁶ cha.Ma. thito @⁷ cha.Ma. idha ⁸ cha.Ma. yatharuta.....

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page159.

Nayo. Yatha ca nibbanam niccam dhuvam, na evam bhattam va yagu va atthi. Kalaparicchedam pana akatva divase divase dassamati pannattivasena ^1- "niccabhattam dhuvayagu"ti vuccatiti ayamettha attho. "atthi puggalo attahitaya patipanno"tiadisupi yatha rupadayo dhamma paccattalakkhanasamannalakkhanavasena atthi, na evam puggalo. Rupadisu pana sati evamnamo evamgottoti voharoti. ^2- Iti imina lokavoharena lokasammatiya lokaniruttiya atthi puggaloti ayamettha attho. Vuttampi cetam bhagavata "ima kho citta lokasamanna lokaniruttiyo lokavohara lokapannattiyo"ti. ^3- Rupadidhamma pana vinapi lokasammatim paccattasamannalakkhanavasena pannapanato atthiti ayamettha attho. Buddhanam pana dve katha sammatikatha ca paramatthakatha ca. Tattha satto puggalo devo brahmatiadika sammatikatha nama. Aniccam dukkham anatta khandha dhatuyo ayatanani satipatthana sammappadhanatiadika paramatthakatha nama. Tattha yo sammatiya desanaya sattoti va .pe. Brahmati vati vutte janitum pativijjhitum niyyatum arahattajayaggaham gahetum sakkoti, tassa bhagava aditova sattoti va puggaloti va posoti va devoti va brahmati va katheti. Yo paramatthadesanaya aniccanti va dukkhanti vatiadisu annataram sutvava janitum pativijjhitum niyyatum arahattajayaggaham gahetum sakkoti, tassa aniccantiadisu annataram katheti. Tatha sammatikathaya bujjhanakasattassa na pathamam paramatthakatham katheti, sammatikathaya pana bodhetva paccha paramatthakatham katheti. Paramatthakathaya bujjhanakasattassapi na pathamam sammatikatham katheti, paramatthakathaya @Footnote: ¹ cha.Ma. pannattavasena ² cha.Ma. voharo hoti ³ di.Si. 9/440/195

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page160.

Pana bodhetva paccha sammatikatham katheti. Pakatiya pana pathamameva ^1- sammatikatham kathetva paccha ^1- paramatthakatham kathentassa desana sukhakara ^2- hoti, tasma buddha pathamam sammatikatham kathetva paccha paramatthakatham kathenti. Te sammatikatham kathentapi saccameva sabhavameva amusava kathenti, paramatthakatham kathentapi saccameva sabhavameva amusava kathenti. Ayanhi:- duve saccani akkhasi sambuddho vadatam varo sammatim paramatthanca tatiyam nupalabbhati. Tattha:- "sanketavacanam saccam lokasammatikaranam paramatthavacanam saccam dhammanam tathalakkhanan"ti. Aparo nayo:- dve bhagavato desana paramatthadesana ca khandhadivasena sammatidesana ca sappikumbhadivasena. Na hi bhagava samannam atidhavati. Tasma "atthi puggalo"ti vacanamattato abhiniveso na katabbo. Satthara hi:- pannattim anatikkamma paramattho pakasito samannam natidhaveyya tasma annopi pandito paramattham pakasento samannam natidhavaye. Sesam sabbattha uttanatthamevati. Puggalakatha nitthita. ---------- @Footnote: ^1-1 cha.Ma. ime patha na dissanti ² cha.Ma. lukhakara

The Pali Atthakatha in Roman Book 55 page 157-160. http://84000.org/tipitaka/atthapali/read_rm.php?B=55&A=3528&modeTY=2&pagebreak=1 อรรถกถาบาลีอักษรไทย :- http://84000.org/tipitaka/atthapali/read_th.php?B=55&A=3528&modeTY=2&pagebreak=1 อ่านอรรถกถาแปลไทย :- http://84000.org/tipitaka/attha/attha.php?b=36&i=525 เนื้อความพระไตรปิฎกฉบับหลวง :- http://84000.org/tipitaka/read/r.php?B=36&A=2516 พระไตรปิฎกฉบับบาลีอักษรไทย :- http://84000.org/tipitaka/read/pali_read.php?B=36&A=2642 The Pali Tipitaka in Roman Character :- http://84000.org/tipitaka/read/roman_read.php?B=36&A=2642 Contents of The Tipitaka Volume 36 http://84000.org/tipitaka/read/?index_36