AtthaPali Vol.47

Bhavetabbaniddesavannana [25] Bhavetabbaniddese kayagatasatiti kayagatasati suttante ^1- vutta anapanacatuiriyapathakhuddakairiyapathadvattimsakaracatudhatunavasivathikapatikulavavatthapaka- manasikarasampayutta yathanurupam rupajjhanasampayutta ca sati. Sa hi tesu kayesu gata pavattati kayagatati vuccati. Satasahagatati madhurasukhavedayitasankhatena satena saha ekuppadadibhavagata. Tabbhave vokinne arammane nissaye samsatthe dissati sahagatasaddo pancasu atthesu jinavacane. "yayam tanha ponobbhavika nandiragasahagata"ti ettha tabbhave, nandiragabhutati ^2- attho. "ya bhikkhave vimamsa kosajjasahagata kosajjasampayutta"ti ^3- ettha vokinne, antarantara uppajjamanena kosajjena vokinnati ^4- attho. "labhi hoti rupasahagatanam va samapattinam arupasahagatanam va samapattinan"ti ettha arammane, ruparuparammanananti attho. "atthikasannasahagatam satisambojjhangam bhaveti"ti ^5- ettha nissaye, atthikasanna- nissayam atthikasannam bhavetva patiladdhanti attho. "idam sukham imaya pitiya sahagatam hoti @Footnote: ¹ Ma.u. 14/153/137 ² abhi.vi. 35/203/120 @³ sam.maha. 19/832/245 ⁴ abhi.pu. 36/3-8/118-9 ⁵ sam.maha. 19/239/114

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page136.

Sahajatam sampayuttan"ti ^1- ettha samsatthe, sammissanti attho. Imasmimpi pade samsatthattho adhippeto. Satasamsattha hi satasahagatati vutta. Sa hi thapetva catutthaj- jhanam sesesu satasahagata hoti, satipi ca upekkhasahagatatte yebhuyyavasena satasahagatati vutta, purimajjhanamulakatta va catutthajjhanassa satasahagataya upekkhasahagatapi vuttava hoti, upekkhaya pana sante sukhe vuttatta bhagavata satasahagatati catutthajjhanasampayuttapi vuttava hoti. Samatho ca vipassana cati kamacchandadayo paccanikadhamme sameti vinasetiti samatho. Samadhissetam namam. Aniccatadivasena vividhehi akarehi dhamme vipassatiti vipassana. Pannayetam namam. Ime pana dve dasuttarapariyaye pubbabhagati vutta, sangitipariyaye ca lokiyalokuttaramissakati. Tayo samadhiti savitakko savicaro samadhi avitakko vicaramatto samadhi avitakko avicaro samadhi. Sampayogavasena vattamanena saha vitakkena savitakko, saha vicarena savicaro. So khanikasamadhi vipassanasamadhi upacarasamadhi pathamajjhanasamadhi. Natthi etassa vitakkoti avitakko. Vitakkavicaresu vicaro matta parama pamanam etassati vicaramatto, vicarato uttari vitakkena sampayogam na gacchatiti attho. So pancakanaye dutiyajjhanasamadhi, tadubhayavirahito avitakko avicaro samadhi. So catukkanaye dutiyajjhanadi, pancakanaye tatiyajjhanadi rupavacarasamadhi. Ime tayopi lokiya eva. Sangitipariyaye aparepi tayo samadhi vutta "sunnato samadhi, animitto samadhi, appanihito samadhi"ti. ^2- Na te idha adhippeta. Cattaro satipatthanati kayanupassanasatipatthanam vedananupassanasatipatthanam cittanupassanasatipatthanam dhammanupassanasatipatthanam. Pubbabhage cuddasavidhena kayam parigganhato kayanupassanasatipatthanam, navavidhena vedanam parigganhato @Footnote: ¹ abhi.vi. 35/588/312 ² di.pa. 11/305/196

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page137.

Vedananupassanasatipatthanam, solasavidhena cittam parigganhato cittanupassana satipatthanam, pancavidhena dhamme parigganhato dhammanupassanasatipatthanam veditabbam. Lokuttaram pana idha na adhippetam. Pancangiko samadhiti panca angani assa santiti pancangiko. Catutthajjhanasamadhi. Pitipharanata sukhapharanata cetopharanata aloka- pharanata paccavekkhananimittanti panca angani. Pitim pharamana uppajjatiti dvisu jhanesu panna pitipharanata nama. Sukham pharamana uppajjatiti tisu jhanesu panna sukhapharanata nama. Paresam ceto pharamana uppajjatiti cetopariyapanna cetopharanata nama. Alokam pharamana uppajjatiti dibbacakkhupanna alokapharanata nama. Paccavekkhanananam paccavekkhananimittam nama. Vuttampi cetam:- "dvisu jhanesu panna pitipharanata, tisu jhanesu panna sukhapharanata, paracittapanna cetopharanata, dibbacakkhupanna alokapharanata, tamha tamha samadhimha vutthitassa paccavekkhanananam paccavekkhananimittan"ti. ^1- Tam hi vutthitasamadhissa pavattakaraggahanato nimittanti vuttam. Tattha ca pitipharanata sukhapharanata dve pada viya, cetopharanata alokapharanata dve hattha viya, abhinnapadakacatutthajjhanam majjhimakayo viya, paccavekkhananimittam sisam viya. Iti ayasma dhammasenapati sariputtatthero pancangikam sammasamadhim angapaccangasampannam purisam viya katva dassesi. Cha anussatitthananiti punappunam uppajjanato satiyo eva anussatiyo, pavattitabbatthanamhiyeva pavattatta saddhapabbajitassa kulaputtassa anurupa satiyotipi anussatiyo eva pitiadinam thanatta anussatitthanani. Katamani cha. @Footnote: ¹ abhi.vi. 35/804/407

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page138.

Buddhanussati dhammanussati samghanussati silanussati caganussati devata- nussati. ^1- Bojjhangati bodhiya, bodhissa va anga. Idam vuttam hoti:- ya esa dhammasamaggi yaya lokuttaramaggakkhane uppajjamanaya linuddhaccapatitthanayuhanakama- sukhattakilamathanuyogaucchedasassatabhinivesadinam anekesam upaddavanam patipakkhabhutaya satidhammavicayaviriyapitipassaddhisamadhiupekkhasankhataya dhammasamaggiya ariyasavako bujjhatiti katva bodhiti vuccati, bujjhatiti kilesasantananiddaya vutthahati, cattari va ariyasaccani pativijjhati, nibbanameva va sacchikaroti, tassa dhammasamaggisankhataya bodhiya angatipi bojjhanga jhanangamaggangadayo viya. Yo cesa ^2- yathavuttappakaraya etaya dhammasamaggiya bujjhatiti katva ariyasavako bodhiti vuccati, tassa bodhissa angati bojjhanga senangarathangadayo viya. Tenahu atthakathacariya "bujjhanakassa puggalassa angati va bojjhanga"ti. Apica "bojjhangati kenatthena bojjhanga, bodhaya samvattantiti bojjhanga"tiadina ^3- na yena bojjhangattho veditabbo. Ariyo atthangiko maggoti tamtammaggavajjhakilesehi arakatta ariyabhavakaratta ariyaphalapatilabhatta ca ariyo. Attha angani assati atthangiko. Soyam caturangika viya sena, pancangikam viya ca turiyam angamattameva hoti, angavinimutto natthi. Bojjhangamagganga lokuttara, dasuttarapariyayena pubbabhagapi labbhanti. Nava parisuddhipadhaniyanganiti silavisuddhi parisuddhipadhaniyangam, cittavisuddhi parisuddhipadhaniyangam, ditthivisuddhi parisuddhipadhaniyangam, kankhavitaranavisuddhi parisuddhipadhaniyangam, maggamaggananadassanavisuddhi parisuddhipadhaniyangam, patipadananadassanavisuddhi parisuddhipadhaniyangam, nanadassanavisuddhi parisuddhipadhaniyangam, pannavisuddhi parisuddhipadhaniyangam, vimuttivisuddhi parisuddhipadhaniyangam. ^4- Silavisuddhiti visuddhim @Footnote: ¹ di.pa. 11/327/220 ² Ma. yo pesa, cha. yo panesa @³ khu.pati. 31/17/327 ⁴ di.pa. 11/359/272

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page139.

Papetum samattham catuparisuddhisilam. Tam hi dussilyamalam visodheti. Parisuddhi- padhaniyanganti parisuddhabhavassa ^1- padhanam uttamam angam. Cittavisuddhiti vipassanaya padatthanabhuta paguna attha samapattiyo. Ta hi kamacchandadicittamalam visodhenti. Ditthivisuddhiti sappaccayanamarupadassanam. Tam hi sattaditthimalam visodheti. Kankhavitaranavisuddhiti paccayakarananam. Tena hi tisu addhasu paccayavasena dhamma pavattantiti passanto tisupi addhasu sattakankhamalam vitaranto visujjhati. Maggamaggananadassanavisuddhiti udayabbayanupassanakkhane uppanna obhasananapiti- passaddhisukhaadhimokkhapaggahaupatthanaupekkhanikantiti dasa vipassanupakkilesa, na maggo, vithipatipannam udayabbayananam maggoti evam maggamagge nanam nama. Tena hi amaggamalam visodheti. Patipadananadassanavisuddhiti vithipatipannam udayabbayanupassana- nanam bhanganupassanananam bhayatupatthananupassanananam adinavanupassanananam nibbidanupassanananam muncitukamyatananam patisankhanupassanananam sankharupekkha- nanam anulomanananti imani nava vipassanananani. Tani hi niccasannadimalam visodhenti. Nanadassanavisuddhiti catuariyamaggapanna. Sa hi samucchedato sakasakamaggavajjhakilesamalam visodheti. Pannati arahattaphalapanna vimuttiti arahattaphalavimutti. Dasa kasinayatananiti "pathavikasinameko sanjanati uddham adho tiriyam advayam appamanam, apokasinameko sanjanati .pe. Tejokasinameko sanjanati. Vayokasinameko sanjanati. Nilakasinameko sanjanati. Pitakasinameko sanjanati. Lohitakasinameko sanjanati. Odatakasinameko sanjanati. Akasakasinameko sanjanati. Vinnanakasinameko sanjanati uddham adho tiriyam advayam appamanan"ti ^2- evam vuttani dasa. Etani hi sakalapharanatthena kasinani, tadarammananam dhammanam @Footnote: ¹ Ma. parisuddhibhavassa ² di.pa. 11/346/237-8, an.dasaka. 24/25/37

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page140.

Khettatthena adhitthanatthena va ayatanani. Uddhanti uparigaganatalabhimukham. Adhoti hetthabhumitalabhimukham. Tiriyanti khettamandalamiva samanta paricchinnam. Ekacco hi uddhameva kasinam vaddheti ekacco adho, ekacco samantato. Ekopi tena tena va karanena evam pasareti alokamiva rupadassanakamo. Tena vuttam "pathavikasinameko sanjanati uddham adho tiriyan"ti. ^1- Advayanti idam pana ekassa annabhavanupagamanattham vuttam. Yatha hi udakam pavitthassa sabbadisasu udakameva hoti na annam, evameva pathavikasinam pathavikasinameva hoti, natthi tassa annakasinasambhedoti. Esa nayo sabbattha. Appamananti idam tassa tassa pharanaappamanavasena vuttam. Tam hi manasa pharanto sakalameva pharati, na ayamassa adi idam majjhanti pamanam ganhatiti. Akasakasinanti kasinugghatimakaso paricchedakasakasinanca. Vinnanakasinanti kasinugghatimakase pavattavinnanam. Tattha kasinavasena kasinugghatimakase kasinugghatimakasavasena tattha pavattavinnane uddhamadhotiriyata veditabba. Paricchedakasakasinassapi vaddhaniyatta tassa vasenapiti. [26] Idani bhavanapabhedam dassento dve bhavanatiadimaha. Tattha lokiyatiadisu loko vuccati lujjanapalujjanatthena vattam, tasmim pariyapannabhavena loke niyuttati lokiya, lokiyanam dhammanam bhavana lokiya. Kincapi dhammanam bhavanati voharavasena vuccati, tehi pana visum bhavana natthi. Te eva hi dhamma bhaviyamana bhavanati vuccanti. Uttinnati uttara, loke apariyapannabhavena lokato uttarati lokuttaRa. Rupabhavasankhate rupe avacarantiti rupavacaRa. Kusalasaddo panettha arogyaanavajjachekasukhavipakesu dissati. "kacci nu bhoto kusalam, kacci nu bhoto @Footnote: ¹ di.pa. 11/347/237, an.dasaka. 24/25/37

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page141.

Anamayan"tiadisu ^1- arogye. "katamo pana bhante kayasamacaro kusalo, yo kho maharaja kayasamacaro anavajjo"ti ^2- ca "puna caparam bhante etadanuttariyam, yatha bhagava dhammam deseti kusalesu dhammesu"ti ^3- ca evamadisu anavajje. "tam kim mannasi rajakumara kusalo tvam rathassa angapaccanganan"ti ^4- "kusala naccagitassa sikkhita caturitthiyo"ti ^5- ca adisu cheke. "kusalanam dhammanam samadanahetu evamidam punnam pavaddhati"ti ^6- "kusalassa kammassa katatta upacitatta"ti ^7- ca adisu sukhavipake. Svayamidha arogyepi anavajjepi sukhavipakepi vattati. Vacanattho panettha kucchite papake dhamme salayanti calayanti kampenti viddhamsentiti kusala. Kucchitena va akarena sayanti pavattantiti kusa. Te akusalasankhatakuse lunanti chindantiti kusala, kucchitanam va sanato tanukaranato kusam, nanam. Tena kusena latabba gahetabba pavattetabbati kusala. Yatha va kusa ubhayabhagagatam hatthappadesam lunanti, evamimepi uppannanuppannabhavena ubhayabhagagatam sankilesapakkham lunanti, tasma kusa viya lunantiti kusala. Tesam rupavacarakusalanam bhavana. Arupabhava- sankhate avacarantiti arupavacaRa. Tebhumakavatte pariyapanna. Antogadhati pariyapanna, tasmim na pariyapannati apariyapanna, lokuttaRa. Kamavacarakusalanam dhammanam bhavana kasma na vuttati ce? appanappattaya Eva bhavanaya abhidhamme bhavanati adhippetatta. Vuttam hi tattha:- "yogavihitesu va kammayatanesu yogavihitesu va sippayatanesu yogavihitesu va vijjatthanesu kammassakatam va saccanulomikam va rupam aniccanti va, vedana aniccati va, sanna aniccati va, @Footnote: ¹ khu.ja. 27/2133/433, khu.ja. 28/151/61 (sya) ² Ma.Ma. 13/361/348 @³ di.pa. 11/145/87 ⁴ Ma.Ma. 13/87/64 @⁵ khu.ja. 28/436/162 (sya) ⁶ di.pa. 11/80/49 ⁷ abhi.san. 34/455/124

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page142.

Sankhara aniccati va, .pe. Vinnanam aniccanti va yam evarupam anulomikam khantim ditthim rucim mudim pekkham dhammanijjhanakkhantim parato asutva patilabhati, ayam vuccati cintamaya panna. Yogavihitesu va kammayatanesu .pe. Dhammanijjhanakkhantim parato sutva patilabhati, ayam vuccati sutamaya panna. Sabbanipi samapannassa panna bhavanamaya panna"ti. ^1- Sa pana kamavacarabhavana avajjanabhavangapatehi antaritatta bhavanati na vuttati veditabba. Sabbesam pana punnanam tividhapunnakiriyavatthuantogadhatta upacarasamadhivipassanasamadhinam bhavanamayapunnata siddha. Idha pana lokiya- bhavanaya ^2- eva sangahita. Ruparupavacaranam tividhabhave. Hinati lamaka. Hinuttamanam majjhe bhava majjha, majjhimatipi patho. Padhanabhavam nitati panita. Uttamati attho. Ayuhanavasena ayam hinamajjhimapanitata veditabba. Yassa hi ayuhanakkhane chando va hino hoti viriyam va cittam va vimamsa va, sa hina nama. Yassa te dhamma majjhima, sa majjhima nama. Yassa te dhamma panita, sa panita nama. Mudukehi va indriyehi sampayutta hina nama, majjhimehi indriyehi sampayutta majjhima, adhimattehi indriyehi sampayutta panita nama. Apariyapannaya hinamajjhimattabhava panitata eva vutta. Sa hi uttamatthena atappakatthena ca panita. [27] Pathamabhavanacatukke bhavetiti ekasmimyeva khane tatha tatha pativijjhanto ariyamaggam bhaveti. Dutiyabhavanacatukke esanabhavanati appana- pubbabhage bhavana. Sa hi appanam esanti etayati esanati vutta. @Footnote: ¹ abhi.vi. 35/868/394 ² Si. lokiyabhavana

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page143.

Patilabhabhavanati appanabhavana. Sa hi taya esanaya patilabbhatiti patilabhoti vutta. Ekarasabhavanati patilabhe vasibhavam pattukamassa payogakale bhavana. Sa hi tena tena pahanena tehi tehi kilesehi vimuttatta vimuttirasena ekarasati katva ekarasati vutta. Asevanabhavanati patilabhe vasippattassa yatharuci paribhogakale bhavana. Sa hi bhusam seviyatiti asevanati vutta. Keci pana "asevanabhavana vasikammam, ekarasabhavana sabbatthika"ti vannayanti. Catukka- vibhage samadhim samapajjantananti vattamanasamipe vattamanavacanam. Tattha jatati tasmim pubbabhage jata. Ekarasa hontiti appanuppadane samanakicca honti. Samadhim samapannananti appitappananam. Tattha jatati tassa appanaya jata. Annamannam nativattantiti samappavattiya annamannam natikkamanti. Adhimokkhatthena saddhindriyam bhavayatotiadisu ekakkhanepi ekekassa indriyassa sakasakakiccakarane tamtamnissayavasena sakasakakiccakaranani sesanipi indriyani vimuttirasena ekarasa hontiti vimuttiraseneva ^1- ekarasatthena bhavana. Balabojjhangamaggangesupi eseva nayo. Ekarasati ca lingavipallaso kato. Idha bhikkhuti imasmim sasane bhikkhu. Samsare bhayam ikkhatiti bhikkhu. Pubbanhasamayantiadisu accantasamyogatthe upayogavacanam, atthato pana bhummameva, divasassa pubbakaleti attho. Asevatiti vasippattasamadhim bhusam sevati. Majjhantika- samayanti divasassa majjhakale. Sayanhasamayanti divasassa sayanhakale. Purebhattanti divabhattato purekale. Pacchabhattanti divabhattato pacchakale. Purimepi yameti rattiya pathame kotthase. Kaleti kalapakkhe. Junheti sukkapakkhe. Purimepi vayokhandheti pathame vayokotthase, pathamavayeti attho. Tisu ca vayesu vassasatayukassa purisassa ekekasmim vaye catumasadhikani tettimsa vassani honti. @Footnote: ¹ Si. vimuttirasavaseneva

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page144.

[28] Tatiyabhavanacatukke tattha jatanam dhammanam anativattanatthenati tattha nekkhammadisu bhavanavisesesu jatanam samadhipannasankhatanam yuganaddhadhammanam annamannam anatikkamanabhavena. Indriyanam ekarasatthenati tattheva saddhadinam indriyanam nanakilesehi vimuttatta vimuttirasena ekarasabhavena. Tadupagaviriya- vahanatthenati tesam anativattanaekarasabhavanam anucchavikassa viriyassa vahanabhavena. Asevanatthenati ya tassa tasmim samaye pavatta asevana, tassa asevanaya asevanabhavena. Rupasannanti kusalavipakakiriyavasena pancadasavidham rupavacarajjhanasankhatam rupasannam. Rupavacarajjhanampi hi rupanti vuccati "rupi rupani passati"tiadisu, ^1- tassa jhanassa arammanampi "bahiddha rupani passati suvannadubbannani"tiadisu. ^2- Rupavacarajjhanam hi sannasisena rupe sannati katva rupasannati vuccati. Patighasannanti kusalavipaka panca, akusalavipaka pancati evam dasavidham patighasannam. Dvipancavinnanasampayutta hi sanna cakkhadinam vatthunam rupadinam arammanananca patighatena uppannatta patighasannati vuccati. Rupasanna saddasanna gandhasanna rasasanna photthabbasannatipi etissa eva namam. Nanattasannanti attha kamavacarakusalasanna, dvadasa akusalasanna, ekadasa kamavacarakusalavipakasanna, dve akusalavipakasanna, ekadasa kamavacarakiriyasannati evam catucattalisavidham nanattasannam. Sa hi nanatte nanasabhave rupasaddadibhede gocare pavatta sannati nanattasanna, catucattalisabhedato nanatta nanasabhava annamannam asadisa sannati va nanattasannati vuccati. Sannabahukattepi jatiggahanena ekavacanam katam. @Footnote: ¹ di.maha. 10/174/100, an.atthaka. 23/163/315 (sya) @² di.maha. 10/173/98, an.atthaka. 23/162/314 (sya) abhi.san. 34/244/74

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page145.

Niccasannanti niccanti sannam niccasannam. Evam sukhasannam attasannam. Nandinti sappitikam tanham. Raganti nippitikam tanham. Samudayanti ragassa samudayam. Atha va bhangasseva dassanato sankharanam udayam. Adananti nibbattanavasena kilesanam, adosadassavitaya sankhatarammanassa va adanam. Ghanasannanti santativasena ghananti sannam. Ayuhananti sankharanam atthaya payogakaranam. Dhuvasannanti thiranti sannam. Nimittanti niccanimittam. Panidhinti sukhapatthanam. Abhinivesanti atthi attati abhinivesam. Saradanabhinivesanti niccasarattasaragahanabhinivesam. Sammohabhinivesanti "ahosim nu kho aham atitamaddhanan"tiadivasena ^1- "issarato loko sambhoti"tiadivasena ca sammohabhinivesam. Alayabhinivesanti adinavadassanena alliyitabbamidanti abhinivesam. Appatisankhanti anupayagahanam. Sannogabhinivesanti kamayogadikam kilesappavattim. Ditthekattheti ditthihi saha ekasmim thitati ditthekattha. Te ditthekatthe. Kilesenti upatapenti, vibadhenti vati kilesa. Te kilese. Duvidham hi ekattham pahanekattham sahajekatthanca. Pahanekattham sakkayaditthippamukhahi tesatthiya ditthihi saha yava sotapattimaggena pahana, tava ekasmim puggale thitati attho. Idamidhadhippetam. Dasasu hi kilesesu idha ditthikilesoyeva agato. Sesesu pana apayagamaniyo lobho doso moho mano vicikiccha thinam uddhaccam ahirikam anottappanti nava kilesa ditthiya saha pahanekattha hutva sotapattimaggena pahiyanti, ragadosamohapamukhesu va diyaddhesu kilesasahassesu sotapattimaggena ditthiya pahiyamanaya ditthiya saha apayagamaniya sabbakilesa pahanekatthavasena pahiyanti, sahajekatthe ditthiya saha ekasmim citte thitati attho. Sotapattimaggena hi dvisu ditthisampayuttaasankharikacittesu pahiyamanesu tehi sahajato lobho moho @Footnote: ¹ sam.ni. 16/20/26

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page146.

Uddhaccam ahirikam anottappanti ime kilesa sahajekatthavasena pahiyanti, dvisu ditthisampayuttasasankharikacittesu pahiyamanesu tehi sahajato lobho moho thinam uddhaccam ahirikam anottappanti ime kilesa sahajekatthavasena pahiyanti. Olarike kileseti olarikabhute kamaragabyapade. Anusahagate kileseti sukhumabhute kamaragabyapade. Sabbakileseti maggattayena pahinavasese. Viriyam vahetiti yogavaro viriyam pavatteti. Hettha esanapatilabhaekarasa- asevanavacanani bhavananam visesadassanattham vuttani "evambhuta ca bhavana"ti. Idha "tattha jatanam dhammanam anativattanatthena indriyanam ekarasatthena tadupagaviriyavahanatthena asevanatthena"ti vacanani bhavanahetudassanattham vuttani "imina ca imina ca hetuna bhavana"ti. Hettha asevana bhavanati nanakkhanavasena vutta idha asevanatthena bhavanati ekakkhanavasenati viseso. Rupam passanto bhavetitiadisu rupadini passitabbakarena passanto bhavetabbam bhavanam bhavetiti attho. Ekarasa hontiti vimuttirasena, kiccarasena va ekarasa honti. Vimuttirasoti sampattiraso. Kiccasampattiatthena raso nama pavuccatiti hi vuttanti. Bhavetabbaniddesavannana nitthita. ------------

The Pali Atthakatha in Roman Book 47 page 135-146. http://84000.org/tipitaka/atthapali/read_rm.php?B=47&A=3019&modeTY=2&pagebreak=1 อรรถกถาบาลีอักษรไทย :- http://84000.org/tipitaka/atthapali/read_th.php?B=47&A=3019&modeTY=2&pagebreak=1 อ่านอรรถกถาแปลไทย :- http://84000.org/tipitaka/attha/attha.php?b=31&i=67 เนื้อความพระไตรปิฎกฉบับหลวง :- http://84000.org/tipitaka/read/r.php?B=31&A=559 พระไตรปิฎกฉบับบาลีอักษรไทย :- http://84000.org/tipitaka/read/pali_read.php?B=31&A=773 The Pali Tipitaka in Roman Character :- http://84000.org/tipitaka/read/roman_read.php?B=31&A=773 Contents of The Tipitaka Volume 31 http://84000.org/tipitaka/read/?index_31