TIPITAKA Volume 37 : PALI ROMAN
Sutta Pitaka Vol 29 : Abhi. Kathāvatthu

page133.
                      Sabbamatthitikatha
     [301]   Sabbamatthiti   .   amanta  .  sabbattha  sabbamatthiti .
Na  hevam  vattabbe  .  sabbamatthiti  .  amanta. Sabbada sabbamatthiti.
Na  hevam  vattabbe  .  sabbamatthiti  .  amanta. Sabbena sabbamatthiti.
Na  hevam  vattabbe  .  sabbamatthiti  .  amanta. Sabbesu sabbamatthiti.
Na   hevam  vattabbe  .  sabbamatthiti  .  amanta  .  ayoganti  katva
sabbamatthiti   .   na   hevam  vattabbe  .  sabbamatthiti  .  amanta .
Yampi   natthi   tampi  atthiti  .  na  hevam  vattabbe  .  sabbamatthiti .
Amanta   .   sabbamatthiti   ya   ditthi   sa  ditthi  micchaditthiti  ya
ditthi sa ditthi sammaditthiti hevamatthiti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [302]  Atitam  atthiti  .  amanta  .  nanu  atitam  niruddham  vigatam
viparinatam   atthangatam   abbhatthangatanti   .   amanta   .   hanci  atitam
niruddham    vigatam    viparinatam   atthangatam   abbhatthangatam   no   vata   re
vattabbe atitam atthiti.
     [303]   Anagatam  atthiti  .  amanta  .  nanu  anagatam  ajatam
abhutam   asanjatam   anibbattam  anabhinibbattam  apatubhutanti  .  amanta .
Hanci    anagatam    ajatam   abhutam   asanjatam   anibbattam   anabhinibbattam
apatubhutam no vata re vattabbe anagatam atthiti.
     [304]   Paccuppannam  atthi  paccuppannam  aniruddham  avigatam  aviparinatam
na   atthangatam   na  abbhatthangatanti  .  amanta  .  atitam  atthi  atitam
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page134.
Aniruddham   avigatam   aviparinatam   na   atthangatam   na   abbhatthangatanti  .
Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [305]   Paccuppannam   atthi   paccuppannam   jatam   bhutam   sanjatam
nibbattam   abhinibbattam   patubhutanti   .   amanta   .   anagatam  atthi
anagatam   jatam   bhutam   sanjatam   nibbattam   abhinibbattam   patubhutanti .
Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [306]   Atitam   atthi   atitam   niruddham  vigatam  viparinatam  atthangatam
abbhatthangatanti   .   amanta  .  paccuppannam  atthi  paccuppannam  niruddham
vigatam viparinatam atthangatam abbhatthangatanti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [307]  Anagatam  atthi  anagatam  ajatam  abhutam  asanjatam anibbattam
anabhinibbattam    apatubhutanti    .    amanta   .   paccuppannam   atthi
paccuppannam  ajatam  abhutam  asanjatam  anibbattam  anabhinibbattam apatubhutanti.
Na hevam vattabbe.
     [308]   Atitam   rupam   atthiti  .  amanta  .  nanu  atitam  rupam
niruddham   vigatam   viparinatam   atthangatam   abbhatthangatanti   .  amanta .
Hanci   atitam  rupam  niruddham  .pe.  abbhatthangatam  no  vata  re  vattabbe
atitam rupam atthiti.
     [309]  Anagatam  rupam  atthiti  .  amanta  .  nanu  anagatam rupam
ajatam    abhutam   asanjatam   anibbattam   anabhinibbattam   apatubhutanti  .
Amanta   .   hanci   anagatam   rupam   ajatam   .pe.  apatubhutam  no
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page135.
Vata re vattabbe anagatam rupam atthiti.
     [310]    Paccuppannam   rupam   atthi   paccuppannam   rupam   aniruddham
avigatam   aviparinatam   na   atthangatam  na  abbhatthangatanti  .  amanta .
Atitam   rupam   atthi  atitam  rupam  aniruddham  avigatam  aviparinatam  na  atthangatam
na abbhatthangatanti. Na hevam vattabbe.
     [311]   Paccuppannam   rupam   atthi   paccuppannam   rupam  jatam  bhutam
sanjatam   nibbattam   abhinibbattam   patubhutanti   .  amanta  .  anagatam
rupam   atthi   anagatam   rupam   jatam   bhutam  sanjatam  nibbattam  abhinibbattam
patubhutanti. Na hevam vattabbe.
     [312]   Atitam   rupam   atthi   atitam  rupam  niruddham  vigatam  viparinatam
atthangatam   abbhatthanganti   .   amanta   .   paccuppannam   rupam  atthi
paccuppannam   rupam   niruddham   vigatam  viparinatam  atthangatam  abbhatthangatanti .
Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [313]  Anagatam  rupam  atthi  anagatam  rupam  ajatam  abhutam asanjatam
anibbattam   anabhinibbattam   apatubhutanti   .   amanta   .   paccuppannam
rupam    atthi   paccuppannam   rupam   ajatam   abhutam   asanjatam   anibbattam
anabhinibbattam apatubhutanti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [314]   Atita   vedana  atthi  .pe.  sanna  atthi  sankhara
atthi   .pe.   vinnanam   atthiti  .  amanta  .  nanu  atitam  vinnanam
niruddham   vigatam   viparinatam   atthangatam   abbhatthangatanti   .  amanta .
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page136.
Hanci   atitam   vinnanam   niruddham   .pe.   abbhatthangatam   no  vata  re
vattabbe atitam vinnanam atthiti.
     [315]  Anagatam  vinnanam  atthiti  .  amanta  .  nanu  anagatam
vinnanam  ajatam  abhutam  asanjatam  anibbattam  anabhinibbattam  apatubhutanti .
Amanta     .     hanci     anagatam    vinnanam    ajatam    .pe.
Apatubhutam no vata re vattabbe anagatam vinnanam atthiti.
     [316]    Paccuppannam    vinnanam    atthi   paccuppannam   vinnanam
aniruddham   .pe.   na   abbhatthangatanti  .  amanta  .  atitam  vinnanam
atthi    atitam    vinnanam   aniruddham   .pe.   na   abbhatthangatanti  .
Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [317]    Paccuppannam    vinnanam    atthi   paccuppannam   vinnanam
jatam   bhutam   .pe.   patubhutanti   .   amanta  .  anagatam  vinnanam
atthi   anagatam   vinnanam   jatam   .pe.   patubhutanti   .   na  hevam
vattabbe .pe.
     [318]   Atitam   vinnanam   atthi   atitam  vinnanam  niruddham  .pe.
Abbhatthangatanti    .    amanta    .    paccuppannam   vinnanam   atthi
paccuppannam   vinnanam   niruddham   .pe.   abbhatthangatanti   .   na  hevam
vattabbe .pe.
     [319]   Anagatam   vinnanam   atthi   anagatam   vinnanam   ajatam
.pe.   apatubhutanti   .   amanta   .   paccuppannam   vinnanam  atthi
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page137.
Paccuppannam   vinnanam   ajatam   abhutam  .pe.  apatubhutanti  .  na  hevam
vattabbe .pe.
     [320]  Paccuppannanti  va  rupanti  va  rupanti  va paccuppannanti
va   paccuppannam   rupam   appiyam   karitva  ese  se  ekatthe  same
samabhage   tajjateti   .   amanta   .  paccuppannam  rupam  nirujjhamanam
paccuppannabhavam   jahatiti  .  amanta  .  rupabhavam  jahatiti  .  na  hevam
vattabbe .pe.
     [321]  Paccuppannanti  va  rupanti  va  rupanti  va paccuppannanti
va   paccuppannam   rupam   appiyam   karitva  ese  se  ekatthe  same
samabhage   tajjateti   .   amanta   .  paccuppannam  rupam  nirujjhamanam
rupabhavam   na   jahatiti   .  amanta  .  paccuppannabhavam  na  jahatiti .
Na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  odatanti  va  vatthanti  va  vatthanti  va
odatanti   va  odatam  vattham  appiyam  karitva  ese  se  ekatthe
same   samabhage  tajjateti  .  amanta  .  odatam  vattham  rajjamanam
odatabhavam   jahatiti   .  amanta  .  vatthabhavam  jahatiti  .  na  hevam
vattabbe  .  odatanti  va  vatthanti  va  vatthanti  va odatanti va
odatam   vattham  appiyam  karitva  ese  se  ekatthe  same  samabhage
tajjateti   .   amanta   .  odatam  vattham  rajjamanam  vatthabhavam  na
jahatiti. Amanta. Odatabhavam na jahatiti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [322]  Rupam  rupabhavam  na  jahatiti  .  amanta  .  rupam niccam dhuvam
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page138.
Sassatam   aviparinamadhammanti   .   na   hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  nanu  rupam
rupabhavam   jahatiti   .   rupam  aniccam  adhuvam  asassatam  viparinamadhammanti .
Amanta    .   hanci   rupam   aniccam   adhuvam   assasatam   viparinamadhammam
no vata re vattabbe rupam rupabhavam na jahatiti.
     [323]  Nibbanam  nibbanabhavam  na  jahatiti  .  nibbanam  niccam  dhuvam
sassatam  aviparinamadhammanti  .  amanta  .  rupam  rupabhavam  na  jahatiti .
Rupam niccam dhuvam sassatam aviparinamadhammanti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [324]  Rupam  rupabhavam  na  jahatiti  .  rupam  aniccam  adhuvam  asassatam
viparinamadhammanti   .  amanta  .  nibbanam  nibbanabhavam  na  jahatiti .
Nibbanam    aniccam   adhuvam   assasatam   viparinamadhammanti   .   na   hevam
vattabbe .pe.
     [325]  Atitam  atthi  atitam  atitabhavam  na  jahatiti  .  amanta.
Anagatam  atthi  anagatam  anagatabhavam  na  jahatiti  .  na hevam vattabbe.
Atitam  atthi  atitam  atitabhavam  na  jahatiti  .  amanta. Paccuppannam atthi
paccuppannam paccuppannabhavam na jahatiti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [326]   Anagatam   atthi   anagatam   anagatabhavam  na  jahatiti .
Amanta   .   atitam   atthi  atitam  atitabhavam  na  jahatiti  .  na  hevam
vattabbe .pe.
     [327]    Paccuppannam    atthi   paccuppannam   paccuppannabhavam   na
jahatiti  .  amanta  .  atitam  atthi  atitam  atitabhavam  na  jahatiti . Na
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page139.
Hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [328]  Atitam  atthi  atitam  atitabhavam  na  jahatiti  .  amanta.
Atitam   niccam   dhuvam   sassatam   aviparinamadhammanti  .  na  hevam  vattabbe
.pe.    nanu   atitam   aniccam   adhuvam   asassatam   viparinamadhammanti  .
Amanta   .   hanci   atitam   aniccam   adhuvam   asassatam   viparinamadhammam
no vata re vattabbe atitam atthi atitam atitabhavam na jahatiti.
     [329]   Nibbanam   atthi   nibbanam   nibbanabhavam  na  jahatiti .
Nibbanam   niccam   dhuvam   sassatam   aviparinamadhammanti   .   amanta  .
Atitam   atthi   atitam  atitabhavam  na  jahatiti  .  atitam  niccam  dhuvam  sassatam
aviparinamadhammanti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [330]   Atitam   atthi   atitam   atitabhavam   na  jahatiti  .  atitam
aniccam   adhuvam   asassatam   viparinamadhammanti   .   amanta  .  nibbanam
atthi   nibbanam   nibbanabhavam   na   jahatiti   .  nibbanam  aniccam  adhuvam
asassatam viparinamadhammanti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [331]  Atitam  rupam atthi atitam rupam atitabhavam na jahatiti. Amanta.
Anagatam  rupam  atthi  anagatam  rupam  anagatabhavam  na  jahatiti  .  na  hevam
vattabbe  .pe.  atitam  rupam  atthi  atitam  rupam  atitabhavam  na  jahatiti .
Amanta   .   paccuppannam   rupam  atthi  paccuppannam  rupam  paccuppannabhavam
na jahatiti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [332]   Anagatam   rupam   atthi   anagatam   rupam  anagatabhavam  na
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page140.
Jahatiti   .   amanta   .   atitam   rupam   atthi  atitam  rupam  atitabhavam
na jahatiti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [333]   Paccuppannam   rupam  atthi  paccuppannam  rupam  paccuppannabhavam
na  jahatiti  .  amanta  .  atitam  rupam  atthi  atitam  rupam  atitabhavam  na
jahatiti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [334]   Atitam   rupam  atthi  atitam  rupam  atitabhavam  na  jahatiti .
Amanta   .   atitam   rupam   niccam   dhuvam  sassatam  aviparinamadhammanti .
Na   hevam   vattabbe   .pe.   nanu  atitam  rupam  aniccam  adhuvam  asassatam
viparinamadhammanti   .   amanta   .   hanci  atitam  rupam  aniccam  .pe.
Viparinamadhammam   no   vata   re   vattabbe   atitam   rupam   atthi  atitam
rupam atitabhavam na jahatiti.
     [335]   Nibbanam  atthi  nibbanam  nibbanabhavam  na  jahati  nibbanam
niccam   dhuvam   sassatam   aviparinamadhammanti   .   amanta  .  atitam  rupam
atthi   atitam   rupam   atitabhavam   na   jahati   atitam   rupam   niccam   dhuvam
sassatam aviparinamadhammanti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [336]   Atitam  rupam  atthi  atitam  rupam  atitabhavam  na  jahati  atitam
rupam    aniccam   adhuvam   asassatam   viparinamadhammanti   .   amanta  .
Nibbanam   atthi   nibbanam   nibbanabhavam   na   jahati   nibbanam   aniccam
adhuvam asassatam viparinamadhammanti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [337]   Atita   vedana   atthi   .pe.  atita  sanna  atthi
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page141.
.pe. Atita sankhara atthi .pe.
     [338]   Atitam   vinnanam   atthi   atitam   vinnanam  atitabhavam  na
jahatiti   .   amanta   .   anagatam  vinnanam  atthi  anagatam  vinnanam
anagatabhavam   na  jahatiti  .  na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  atitam  vinnanam
atthi    atitam   vinnanam   atitabhavam   na   jahatiti   .   amanta  .
Paccuppannam    vinnanam    atthi    paccuppannam   vinnanam   paccuppannabhavam
na jahatiti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [339]   Anagatam   vinnanam  atthi  anagatam  vinnanam  anagatabhavam
na   jahatiti   .   amanta   .   atitam  vinnanam  atthi  atitam  vinnanam
atitabhavam na jahatiti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [340]    Paccuppannam    vinnanam    atthi   paccuppannam   vinnanam
paccuppannabhavam   na   jahatiti   .   amanta   .  atitam  vinnanam  atthi
atitam vinnanam atitabhavam na jahatiti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [341]    Atitam    vinnanam   atthi   atitam   vinnanam   atitabhavam
na   jahatiti   .   amanta   .   atitam   vinnanam   niccam  dhuvam  sassatam
aviparinamadhammanti   .   na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  nanu  atitam  vinnanam
aniccam   adhuvam   asassatam   viparinamadhammanti   .   amanta   .   hanci
atitam    vinnanam   aniccam   adhuvam   asassatam   viparinamadhammam   no   vata
re   vattabbe   atitam   vinnanam   atthi   atitam  vinnanam  atitabhavam  na
jahatiti.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page142.
     [342]   Nibbanam  atthi  nibbanam  nibbanabhavam  na  jahati  nibbanam
niccam    dhuvam    sassatam   aviparinamadhammanti   .   amanta   .   atitam
vinnanam    atthi    atitam    vinnanam    atitabhavam    na   jahati   atitam
vinnanam    niccam    dhuvam    sassatam   aviparinamadhammanti   .   na   hevam
vattabbe .pe.
     [343]    Atitam    vinnanam   atthi   atitam   vinnanam   atitabhavam
na   jahati   atitam   vinnanam  aniccam  adhuvam  asassatam  viparinamadhammanti .
Amanta    .    nibbanam   atthi   nibbanam   nibbanabhavam   na   jahati
nibbanam    aniccam   adhuvam   assasatam   viparinamadhammanti   .   na   hevam
vattabbe .pe.
     [344]   Atitam   nvatthiti   .  amanta  .  hanci  atitam  nvatthi
atitam   atthiti   miccha   hanci  va  pana  atthi  nvatitam  atthi  atitanti
miccha   .   anagatam  nvatthiti  .  amanta  .  hanci  anagatam  nvatthi
anagatam   atthiti    miccha   hanci   va   pana  atthi  nvanagatam  atthi
anagatanti miccha.
     [345]   Anagatam   hutva   paccuppannam  hotiti  .  amanta .
Tanneva   anagatam   tam   paccuppannanti   .  na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.
Tanneva   anagatam   tam   paccuppannanti   .  amanta  .  hutva  hoti
hutva   hotiti   .   na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  hutva  hoti  hutva
hotiti  .  amanta  .  na  hutva  na  hoti  na  hutva na hotiti. Na
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page143.
Hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [346]  Paccuppannam  hutva  atitam  hotiti  .  amanta. Tanneva
paccuppannam   tam   atitanti   .   na   hevam   vattabbe  .pe.  tanneva
paccuppannam   tam   atitanti   .   amanta   .   hutva   hoti  hutva
hotiti  .  na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  hutva  hoti  hutva  hotiti .
Amanta   .   na   hutva   na   hoti  na  hutva  na  hotiti  .  na
hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [347]   Anagatam   hutva   paccuppannam  hoti  paccuppannam  hutva
atitam   hotiti   .   amanta   .   tanneva   anagatam  tam  paccuppannam
tam   atitanti   .   na   hevam   vattabbe  .pe.  tanneva  anagatam  tam
paccuppannam   tam   atitanti   .   amanta   .   hutva   hoti  hutva
hotiti  .  na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  hutva  hoti  hutva  hotiti .
Amanta   .   na   hutva   na   hoti  na  hutva  na  hotiti  .  na
hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [348]   Atitam   cakkhum   atthi   rupa   atthi  cakkhuvinnanam  atthi
aloko   atthi  manasikaro  atthiti  .  amanta  .  atitena  cakkhuna
atitam   rupam   passatiti   .   na   hevam   vattabbe  .pe.  atitam  sotam
atthi   sadda   atthi   sotavinnanam   atthi  akaso  atthi  manasikaro
atthiti   .   amanta   .  atitena  sotena  atitam  saddam  sunatiti .
Na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  atitam  ghanam  atthi  gandha  atthi ghanavinnanam
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page144.
Atthi    vayo    atthi    manasikaro    atthiti    .   amanta  .
Atitena   ghanena  atitam  gandham  ghayatiti  .  na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.
Atita   jivha   atthi   rasa   atthi   jivha   vinnanam  atthi  apo
atthi   manasikaro   atthiti   .   amanta  .  atitaya  jivhaya  atitam
rasam   sayatiti   .   na   hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  atito  kayo  atthi
photthabba    atthi    kayavinnanam    atthi   pathavi   atthi   manasikaro
atthiti   .  amanta  .  atitena  kayena  atitam  photthabbam  phusatiti .
Na   hevam   vattabbe   .pe.   atito   mano   atthi   dhamma   atthi
manovinnanam   atthi   vatthum   atthi  manasikaro  atthiti  .  amanta .
Atitena manena atitam dhammam vijanatiti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [349]    Anagatam    cakkhum   atthi   rupa   atthi   cakkhuvinnanam
atthi   aloko  atthi  manasikaro  atthiti  .  amanta  .  anagatena
cakkhuna  anagatam  rupam  passatiti  .  na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  anagatam
sotam  atthi  ghanam  atthi  jivha  atthi  kayo  atthi  mano  atthi dhamma
atthi    manovinnanam    atthi   vatthum   atthi   manasikaro   atthiti  .
Amanta   .   anagatena   manena   anagatam  dhammam  vijanatiti  .  na
hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [350]   Paccuppannam   cakkhum   atthi   rupa   atthi   cakkhuvinnanam
atthi    aloko   atthi   manasikaro   atthi   paccuppannena   cakkhuna
paccuppannam   rupam   passatiti   .   amanta   .   atitam   cakkhum   atthi
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page145.
Rupa    atthi    cakkhuvinnanam    atthi    aloko   atthi   manasikaro
atthi   atitena   cakkhuna   atitam  rupam  passatiti  .  na  hevam  vattabbe
.pe.    paccuppannam    sotam    atthi    ghanam   atthi   jivha   atthi
kayo    atthi    mano    atthi   dhamma   atthi   manovinnanam   atthi
vatthum    atthi   manasikaro   atthi   paccuppannena   manena   paccuppannam
dhammam   vijanatiti   .   amanta   .   atito   mano   atthi  dhamma
atthi     manovinnanam    atthi    vatthum    atthi    manasikaro    atthi
atitena manena atitam dhammam vijanatiti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [351]   Paccuppannam   cakkhum   atthi   rupa   atthi   cakkhuvinnanam
atthi    aloko   atthi   manasikaro   atthi   paccuppannena   cakkhuna
paccuppannam   rupam   passatiti   .   amanta   .   anagatam  cakkhum  atthi
rupa    atthi    cakkhuvinnanam    atthi    aloko   atthi   manasikaro
atthi   anagatena   cakkhuna   anagatam   rupam   passatiti   .   na  hevam
vattabbe    .pe.   paccuppannam   sotam   atthi   .pe.   ghanam   atthi
jivha   atthi   kayo   atthi   mano  atthi  dhamma  atthi  manovinnanam
atthi    vatthum    atthi    manasikaro    atthi    paccuppannena   manena
paccuppannam    dhammam    vijanatiti    .    amanta    .    anagato
mano    atthi    dhamma    atthi    manovinnanam   atthi   vatthum   atthi
manasikaro   atthi   anagatena   manena   anagatam  dhammam  vijanatiti .
Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page146.
     [352]   Atitam   cakkhum   atthi   rupa   atthi  cakkhuvinnanam  atthi
aloko   atthi   manasikaro   atthi   na   ca  atitena  cakkhuna  atitam
rupam   passatiti   .   amanta   .   paccuppannam   cakkhum   atthi   rupa
atthi    cakkhuvinnanam    atthi    aloko    atthi   manasikaro   atthi
na   ca   paccuppannena   cakkhuna   paccuppannam   rupam   passatiti   .  na
hevam   vattabbe   .pe.   atitam   sotam   atthi   .pe.   ghanam  atthi
jivha   atthi   kayo   atthi   .pe.   mano   atthi   dhamma   atthi
manovinnanam   atthi   vatthum   atthi   manasikaro   atthi  na  ca  atitena
manena  atitam  dhammam  vijanatiti  .  amanta  .  paccuppanno mano atthi
dhamma    atthi    manovinnanam    atthi    vatthum    atthi    manasikaro
atthi   na   ca   paccuppannena  manena  paccuppannam  dhammam  vijanatiti .
Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [353]    Anagatam    cakkhum   atthi   rupa   atthi   cakkhuvinnanam
atthi    aloko    atthi    manasikaro   atthi   na   ca   anagatena
cakkhuna    anagatam    rupam   passatiti   .   amanta   .   paccuppannam
cakkhum    atthi    rupa   atthi   cakkhuvinnanam   atthi   aloko   atthi
manasikaro   atthi   na   ca   paccuppannena   cakkhuna   paccuppannam  rupam
passatiti   .   na   hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  anagatam  sotam  atthi  ghanam
atthi   jivha   atthi   kayo   atthi   .pe.   mano   atthi   dhamma
atthi     manovinnanam    atthi    vatthum    atthi    manasikaro    atthi
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page147.
Na   ca  anagatena  manena  anagatam  dhammam  vijanatiti  .  amanta .
Paccuppanno    mano    atthi    dhamma    atthi    manovinnanam   atthi
vatthum    atthi    manasikaro    atthi   na   ca   paccuppannena   manena
paccuppannam dhammam vijanatiti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [354]   Atitam   nanam   atthiti  .  amanta  .  tena  nanena
nanakaraniyam   karotiti   .   na   hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  tena  nanena
nanakaraniyam   karotiti  .  amanta  .  tena  nanena  dukkham  parijanati
samudayam   pajahati   nirodham   sacchikaroti   maggam   bhavetiti   .  na  hevam
vattabbe .pe.
     [355]   Anagatam  nanam  atthiti  .  amanta  .  tena  nanena
nanakaraniyam   karotiti   .   na   hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  tena  nanena
nanakaraniyam   karotiti  .  amanta  .  tena  nanena  dukkham  parijanati
samudayam   pajahati   nirodham   sacchikaroti    maggam   bhavetiti  .  na  hevam
vattabbe .pe.
     [356]   Paccuppannam   nanam   atthi   tena   nanena  nanakaraniyam
karotiti    .   amanta   .   atitam   nanam   atthi   tena   nanena
nanakaraniyam   karotiti   .   na   hevam   vattabbe   .pe.   paccuppannam
nanam    atthi    tena   nanena   dukkham   parijanati   samudayam   pajahati
nirodham   sacchikaroti   maggam   bhavetiti   .   amanta  .  atitam  nanam
atthi    tena   nanena   dukkham   parijanati   samudayam   pajahati   nirodham
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page148.
Sacchikaroti   maggam  bhavetiti  .  na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  paccuppannam
nanam   atthi   tena   nanena   nanakaraniyam   karotiti  .  amanta .
Anagatam    nanam    atthi   tena   nanena   nanakaraniyam   karotiti  .
Na   hevam   vattabbe   .pe.   paccuppannam  nanam  atthi  tena  nanena
dukkham    parijanati    samudayam    pajahati    nirodham    sacchikaroti   maggam
bhavetiti   .   amanta   .   anagatam   nanam   atthi  tena  nanena
dukkham    parijanati    samudayam    pajahati    nirodham    sacchikaroti   maggam
bhavetiti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [357]   Atitam   nanam   atthi  na  ca  tena  nanena  nanakaraniyam
karotiti   .   amanta   .   paccuppannam   nanam   atthi  na  ca  tena
nanena   nanakaraniyam   karotiti   .   na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  atitam
nanam    atthi   na   ca   tena   nanena   dukkham   parijanati   samudayam
pajahati    nirodham    sacchikaroti   maggam   bhavetiti   .   amanta  .
Paccuppannam   nanam   atthi   na   ca   tena   nanena  dukkham  parijanati
samudayam   pajahati   nirodham   sacchikaroti   maggam   bhavetiti   .  na  hevam
vattabbe .pe.
     [358]   Anagatam  nanam  atthi  na  ca  tena  nanena  nanakaraniyam
karotiti   .   amanta   .   paccuppannam   nanam   atthi  na  ca  tena
nanena   nanakaraniyam   karotiti  .  na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  anagatam
nanam    atthi   na   ca   tena   nanena   dukkham   parijanati   samudayam
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page149.
Pajahati    nirodham    sacchikaroti   maggam   bhavetiti   .   amanta  .
Paccuppannam   nanam   atthi   na   ca   tena   nanena  dukkham  parijanati
samudayam   pajahati   nirodham   sacchikaroti   maggam   bhavetiti   .  na  hevam
vattabbe .pe.
     [359]  Arahato  atito  rago  atthiti  .  amanta  .  araha
tena  ragena  saragoti  .  na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  arahato atito
doso   atthiti   .  amanta  .  araha  tena  dosena  sadosoti .
Na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  arahato  atito  moho atthiti. Amanta.
Araha   tena   mohena   samohoti   .   na   hevam  vattabbe  .pe.
Arahato  atito  mano  atthiti  .  amanta  .  araha  tena  manena
samanoti   .   na   hevam   vattabbe   .pe.   arahato  atita  ditthi
atthiti   .   amanta   .   araha  taya  ditthiya  saditthikoti  .  na
hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  arahato  atita  vicikiccha  atthiti. Amanta.
Araha   taya   vicikicchaya  savicikicchoti  .  na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.
Arahato   atitam   thinam   atthiti   .  amanta  .  araha  tena  thinena
sathinoti   .   na   hevam   vattabbe   .pe.   arahato  atitam  uddhaccam
atthiti   .  amanta  .  araha  tena  uddhaccena  sauddhaccoti  .  na
hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  arahato  atitam  ahirikam  atthiti  .  amanta .
Araha   tena   ahirikena   saahirikoti   .  na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.
Arahato   atitam   anottappam   atthiti   .   amanta  .  araha  tena
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page150.
Anottappena saanottappiti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [360]  Anagamissa  atita  sakkayaditthi  atthiti  .  amanta.
Anagami   taya   ditthiya   saditthikoti  .  na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.
Anagamissa    atita    vicikiccha    atthi   atito   silabbataparamaso
atthi    atito    anusahagato   kamarago   atthi   atito   anusahagato
byapado   atthiti   .   amanta   .   anagami  tena  byapadena
byapannacittoti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [361]  Sakadagamissa  atita  sakkayaditthi  atthiti . Amanta.
Sakadagami   taya   ditthiya  saditthikoti  .  na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.
Sakadagamissa    atita    vicikiccha   atthi   atito   silabbataparamaso
atthi    atito    olariko   kamarago   atthi   atito   olariko
byapado   atthiti   .   amanta   .  sakadagami  tena  byapadena
byapannacittoti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [362]  Sotapannassa  atita  sakkayaditthi  atthiti . Amanta.
Sotapanno   taya   ditthiya   saditthikoti   .   na   hevam   vattabbe
.pe.   sotapannassa  atita  vicikiccha  atthi  atito  silabbataparamaso
atthi    atito   apayagamaniyo   rago   atthi   atito   apayagamaniyo
doso   atthi   atito   apayagamaniyo  moho  atthiti  .  amanta .
Sotapanno tena mohena samohoti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page151.
     [363]  Puthujjanassa  atito  rago  atthi  puthujjano  tena ragena
saragoti   .   amanta   .   arahato   atito  rago  atthi  araha
tena   ragena   saragoti   .  na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  puthujjanassa
atito   doso   atthi   .pe.   atitam   anottappam   atthi   puthujjano
tena   anottappena   anottappiti   .   amanta   .  arahato  atitam
anottappam   atthi   araha   tena   anottappena   anottappiti  .  na
hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [364]   Puthujjanassa   atita  sakkayaditthi  atthi  puthujjano  taya
ditthiya   saditthikoti  .  amanta  .  anagamissa  atita  sakkayaditthi
atthi   anagami   taya   ditthiya   saditthikoti  .  na  hevam  vattabbe
.pe.   puthujjanassa   atita  vicikiccha  atthi  .pe.  atito  anusahagato
byapado   atthi   puthujjano   tena   byapadena  byapannacittoti .
Amanta    .   anagamissa   atito   anusahagato   byapado   atthi
anagami tena byapadena byapannacittoti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [365]    Puthujjanassa    atita   sakkayaditthi   atthi   puthujjano
taya   ditthiya   saditthikoti   .   amanta   .  sakadagamissa  atita
sakkayaditthi   atthi   sakadagami   taya   ditthiya   saditthikoti   .  na
hevam   vattabbe   .pe.   puthujjanassa   atita  vicikiccha  atthi  .pe.
Atito   olariko   byapado   atthi   puthujjano   tena  byapadena
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page152.
Byapannacittoti   .   amanta   .   sakadagamissa  atito  olariko
byapado   atthi   sakadagami   tena  byapadena  byapannacittoti .
Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [366]   Puthujjanassa   atita  sakkayaditthi  atthi  puthujjano  taya
ditthiya    saditthikoti    .    amanta    .   sotapannassa   atita
sakkayaditthi   atthi   sotapanno   taya   ditthiya   saditthikoti  .  na
hevam   vattabbe   .pe.   puthujjanassa   atita  vicikiccha  atthi  .pe.
Atito    apayagamaniyo    moho    atthi   puthujjano   tena   mohena
samohoti    .   amanta   .   sotapannassa   atito   apayagamaniyo
moho   atthi   sotapanno   tena   mohena   samohoti  .  na  hevam
vattabbe .pe.
     [367]  Arahato  atito  rago  atthi  na  ca araha tena ragena
saragoti   .   amanta   .  puthujjanassa  atito  rago  atthi  na  ca
puthujjano   tena   ragena   saragoti   .  na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.
Arahato   atito   doso   atthi   .pe.   atitam  anottappam  atthi  na
ca    araha   tena   anottappena   anottappiti   .   amanta  .
Puthujjanassa    atitam    anottappam    atthi   na   ca   puthujjano   tena
anottappena anottappiti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [368]  Anagamissa  atita  sakkayaditthi  atthi  na  ca  anagami
taya   ditthiya   saditthikoti   .   amanta   .   puthujjanassa   atita
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page153.
Sakkayaditthi   atthi   na   ca   puthujjano  taya  ditthiya  saditthikoti .
Na   hevam   vattabbe   .pe.   anagamissa   atita   vicikiccha  atthi
.pe.    atito   anusahagato   byapado   atthi   na   ca   anagami
tena   byapadena   byapannacittoti   .   amanta   .   puthujjanassa
atito    anusahagato    byapado   atthi   na   ca   puthujjano   tena
byapadena byapannacittoti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [369]    Sakadagamissa   atita   sakkayaditthi   atthi   na   ca
sakadagami   taya   ditthiya   saditthikoti   .  amanta  .  puthujjanassa
atita    sakkayaditthi    atthi    na   ca   puthujjano   taya   ditthiya
saditthikoti   .   na   hevam   vattabbe   .pe.   sakadagamissa  atita
vicikiccha   atthi   .pe.   atito   olariko   byapado   atthi  na
ca   sakadagami   tena   byapadena  byapannacittoti  .  amanta .
Puthujjanassa   atito   olariko   byapado   atthi   na  ca  puthujjano
tena byapadena byapannacittoti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [370]    Sotapannassa   atita   sakkayaditthi   atthi   na   ca
sotapanno   taya   ditthiya   saditthikoti  .  amanta  .  puthujjanassa
atita  sakkayaditthi  atthi  na  ca  puthujjano  taya  ditthiya saditthikoti.
Na   hevam   vattabbe   .pe.   sotapannassa   atita  vicikiccha  atthi
.pe.   atito   apayagamaniyo  moho  atthi  na  ca  sotapanno  tena
mohena   samohoti   .  amanta  .  puthujjanassa  atito  apayagamaniyo
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page154.
Moho    atthi   na   ca   puthujjano   tena   mohena   samohoti  .
Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [371]  Atita  hattha  atthiti  .  amanta  .  atitesu hatthesu
sati   adananikkhepanam   pannayatiti   .   na   hevam   vattabbe  .pe.
Atita   pada   atthiti   .   amanta   .   atitesu   padesu  sati
abhikkamapatikkamo   pannayatiti   .   na   hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  atita
pabba  atthiti  .  amanta  .  atitesu  pabbesu  sati  samminjanapasaranam
pannayatiti   .   na   hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  atito  kucchi  atthiti .
Amanta   .   atitasmim   kucchismim   sati  jighacchapipasa  pannayatiti .
Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     {371.1}  Atito  kayo  atthiti  .  amanta  .  atito kayo
paggahaniggahupago     chedanabhedanupago     kakehi    gijjhehi    kulalehi
sadharanoti  .  na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  atite  kaye  visam kameyya
sattham  kameyya  aggi  kameyyati  .  na  hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  labbha
atito     kayo    addubandhanena    bandhitum    rajjubandhanena    bandhitum
sankhalikabandhanena     bandhitum     gamabandhanena    bandhitum    nigamabandhanena
bandhitum      nagarabandhanena      bandhitum      janapadabandhanena      bandhitum
kanthapancamehi bandhanehi bandhitunti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [372]   Atito  apo  atthiti  .  amanta  .  tena  apena
apakaraniyam   karotiti   .   na   hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  atito  tejo
atthiti   .   amanta   .  tena  tejena  tejakaraniyam  karotiti  .  na
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page155.
Hevam   vattabbe  .pe.  atito  vayo  atthiti  .  amanta  .  tena
vayena vayakaraniyam karotiti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [373]   Atito   rupakkhandho   atthi  anagato  rupakkhandho  atthi
paccuppanno  rupakkhandho  atthiti  .  amanta  .  tayo  rupakkhandhati .
Na   hevam   vattabbe   .pe.   atita   pancakkhandha   atthi  anagata
pancakkhandha    atthi    .    paccuppanna    pancakkhandha   atthiti  .
Amanta. Pannarasakhandhati. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [374]   Atitam   cakkhayatanam   atthi   anagatam   cakkhayatanam  atthi
paccuppannam  cakkhayatanam  atthiti  .  amanta  .  tini  cakkhayatananiti .
Na   hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  atitani  dvadasayatanani  atthi  anagatani
dvadasayatanani    atthi   paccuppannani   dvadasayatanani   atthiti  .
Amanta. Chattimsayatananiti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [375]   Atita   cakkhudhatu   atthi   anagata   cakkhudhatu  atthi
paccuppanna  cakkhudhatu  atthiti  .  amanta  .  tisso  cakkhudhatuyoti.
Na   hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  atita  attharasa  dhatuyo  atthi  anagata
attharasa   dhatuyo   atthi   paccuppanna  attharasa  dhatuyo  atthiti .
Amanta. Catupannasa dhatuyoti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [376]   Atitam   cakkhundriyam   atthi   anagatam   cakkhundriyam  atthi
paccuppannam  cakkhundriyam  atthiti  .  amanta  .  tini  cakkhundriyaniti .
Na   hevam  vattabbe  .pe.  atitani  bavisatindriyani  atthi  anagatani
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page156.
Bavisatindriyani    atthi   paccuppannani   bavisatindriyani   atthiti  .
Amanta. Chasatthindriyaniti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [377]  Atito  raja  cakkavatti  atthi  anagato raja cakkavatti
atthi   paccuppanno   raja   cakkavatti  atthiti  .  amanta  .  tinnam
rajunam cakkavattinam sammukhibhavo hotiti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [378]   Atito   sammasambuddho  atthi  anagato  sammasambuddho
atthi   paccuppanno   sammasambuddho   atthiti   .   amanta  .  tinnam
sammasambuddhanam sammukhibhavo hotiti. Na hevam vattabbe .pe.
     [379]  Atitam  atthiti  .  amanta  .  atthi  atitanti  .  atthi
siya   atitam   siya   nvatitanti   .   ajanahi  niggaham  hanci  atitam
atthi   atthi   siya   atitam  siya  nvatitam  tenatitam  nvatitam  nvatitam
atitanti   yam   tattha   vadesi   vattabbe  kho  atitam  atthi  atthi  siya
atitam   siya   nvatitam   tenatitam   nvatitam   nvatitam  atitanti  miccha
no  ce  pana  atitam  nvatitam  nvatitam  atitanti  no  vata  re vattabbe
atitam   atthi   atthi   siya   atitam  siya  nvatitanti  yam  tattha  vadesi
vattabbe  kho  atitam  atthi  atthi  siya  atitam  siya  nvatitam  tenatitam
nvatitam navatitam atitanti miccha.
     [380]   Anagatam  atthiti  .  amanta  .  atthi  anagatanti .
Atthi   siya   anagatam   siya   nvanagatanti   .   ajanahi  niggaham
hanci   anagatam   atthi   atthi   siya  anagatam  siya  nvanagatam  tena
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page157.
Anagatam   nvanagatam  nvanagatam  anagatanti  yam  tattha  vadesi  vattabbe
kho   anagatam   atthi   atthi   siya   anagatam  siya  nvanagatam  tena
anagatam   nvanagatam   nvanagatam   anagatanti   miccha   no  ce  pana
anagatam   nvanagatam   nvanagatam   anagatanti  no  vata  re  vattabbe
anagatam   atthi   atthi   siya   anagatam  siya  nvanagatanti  yam  tattha
vadesi   vattabbe   kho   anagatam   atthi   atthi  siya  anagatam  siya
nvanagatam tena anagatam nvanagatam nvanagatam anagatanti miccha.
     [381]  Paccuppannam  atthiti  .  amanta . Atthi paccuppannanti.
Atthi    siya    paccuppannam   siya   nopaccuppannanti   .   ajanahi
niggaham    hanci   paccuppannam   atthi   atthi   siya   paccuppannam   siya
nopaccuppannam     tena     paccuppannam    nopaccuppannam    nopaccuppannam
paccuppannanti   yam   tattha   vadesi   vattabbe   kho   paccuppannam  atthi
atthi    siya    paccuppannam   siya   nopaccuppannam   tena   paccuppannam
nopaccuppannam   nopaccuppannam   paccuppannanti   miccha   no   ce   pana
paccuppannam    nopaccuppannam    nopaccuppannam   paccuppannanti   no   vata
re   vattabbe   paccuppannam   atthi   atthi   siya   paccuppannam   siya
nopaccuppannanti    yam    tattha    vadesi   vattabbe   kho   paccuppannam
atthi   atthi   siya   paccuppannam  siya  nopaccuppannam  tena  paccuppannam
nopaccuppannam nopaccuppannam paccuppannanti miccha.
     [382]   Nibbanam  atthiti  .  amanta  .  atthi  nibbananti .
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page158.
Atthi   siya   nibbanam   siya   nonibbananti   .   ajanahi  niggaham
hanci   nibbanam   atthi   atthi   siya  nibbanam  siya  nonibbanam  tena
nibbanam    nonibbanam    nonibbanam    nibbananti   yam   tattha   vadesi
vattabbe   kho   nibbanam  atthi  atthi  siya  nibbanam  siya  nonibbanam
tena    nibbanam    nonibbanam   nonibbanam   nibbananti   miccha   no
ce   pana   nibbanam   nonibbanam   nonibbanam   nibbananti   no   vata
re  vattabbe  nibbanam  atthi  atthi  siya  nibbanam  siya  nonibbananti
yam    tattha   vadesi   vattabbe   kho   nibbanam   atthi   atthi   siya
nibbanam   siya   nonibbanam   tena   nibbanam   nonibbanam   nonibbanam
nibbananti miccha.
     [383]  Na  vattabbam  atitam  atthi  anagatam  atthiti . Amanta.
Nanu   vuttam   bhagavata   yam   kinci   bhikkhave  rupam  atitanagatapaccuppannam
ajjhattam   va  bahiddha  va  olarikam  va  sukhumam  va  hinam  va  panitam
va   yam   dure   santike   va   ayam   vuccati  rupakkhandho  ya  kaci
vedana  .pe.  ya  kaci  sanna  .pe.  ye  keci  sankhara  .pe.
Yam    kinci   vinnanam   atitanagatapaccuppannam   ajjhattam   va   bahiddha
va  olarikam  va  sukhumam  va  hinam  va  panitam  va yam dure santike va
ayam   vuccati   vinnanakkhandhoti   attheva   suttantoti  .  amanta .
Tena hi atitam atthi anagatam atthiti.
     [384]  Atitam  atthi  anagatam  atthiti  .  amanta  .  nanu vuttam
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page159.
Bhagavata    tayome    bhikkhave   niruttipatha   adhivacanapatha   pannattipatha
asankinna     asankinnapubba     na    sankiyanti    na    sankiyissanti
appatikkuttha   samanehi   brahmanehi   vinnuhi  .  katame  tayo  .  yam
bhikkhave  rupam  atitam  niruddham  vigatam  viparinatam  ahositi  tassa sankha ahositi
tassa   samanna   ahositi   tassa   pannatti   na   tassa  sankha  atthiti
na   tassa   sankha  bhavissatiti  ya  vedana  .pe.  ya  sanna  .pe.
Ye   sankhara   .pe.   yam   vinnanam   atitam   niruddham  vigatam  viparinatam
ahositi    tassa   sankha   ahositi   tassa   samanna   ahositi   tassa
pannatti na tassa sankha atthiti na tassa sankha bhavissatiti
     {384.1}   yam   bhikkhave  rupam  ajatam  apatubhutam  bhavissatiti  tassa
sankha    bhavissatiti   tassa   samanna   bhavissatiti   tassa   pannatti   na
tassa  sankha  atthiti  na  tassa  sankha  ahositi  ya  vedana .pe. Ya
sanna   .pe.   ye   sankhara  .pe.  yam  vinnanam  ajatam  apatubhutam
bhavissatiti    tassa    sankha    bhavissatiti    tassa   samanna   bhavissatiti
tassa   pannatti   na   tassa   sankha  atthiti  na  tassa  sankha  ahositi
yam   bhikkhave   rupam   jatam  patubhutam  atthiti  tassa  sankha  atthiti  tassa
samanna   atthiti   tassa   pannatti  na  tassa  sankha  ahositi  na  tassa
sankha  bhavissatiti  ya  vedana  .pe.  ya  sanna  .pe. Ye sankhara
.pe.   yam   vinnanam   jatam   patubhutam   atthiti   tassa  sankha  atthiti
tassa   samanna   atthiti   tassa   pannatti   na   tassa  sankha  ahositi
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page160.
Na   tassa   sankha   bhavissatiti   ime   kho  bhikkhave  tayo  niruttipatha
adhivacanapatha      pannattipatha     asankinna     asankinnapubba     na
sankiyanti    na    sankiyissanti    appatikkuttha   samanehi   brahmanehi
vinnuhi
     {384.2} yepi te bhikkhave ahesum ukkala vassabhanna  ahetukavada
akiriyavada   natthikavada   tepime   tayo   niruttipathe    adhivacanapathe
pannattipathe   na   garahitabbam   na   patikkositabbam  amannimsu  .  tam  kissa
hetu   .   nindabyarosanauparambhabhayati  1-  attheva  suttantoti .
Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam atitam atthi anagatam atthiti.
     [385]   Atitam  atthiti  .  amanta  .  nanu  ayasma  phagguno
bhagavantam   etadavoca   atthi   nu  kho  tam  bhante  cakkhum  yena  cakkhuna
atite   buddhe   parinibbute   chinnapapance   chinnavatume  pariyadinnavatte
sabbadukkhavitivatte    pannapayamano    pannapeyya   .pe.   atthi   nu
kho  sa  bhante  jivha  .pe.  atthi nu kho so bhante mano yena manena
atite   buddhe   parinibbute   chinnapapance   chinnavatume  pariyadinnavatte
sabbadukkhavitivatte pannapayamano pannapeyyati.
     {385.1}  Natthi  kho  tam  phagguna  cakkhum yena cakkhuna atite buddhe
parinibbute   chinnapapance   chinnavatume  pariyadinnavatte  sabbadukkhavitivatte
pannapayamano  pannapeyya  .pe.  natthi  kho  sa  phagguna jivha .pe.
Natthi  kho so phagguna mano yena manena atite buddhe parinibbute chinnapapance
@Footnote: 1 sam. khu. 64.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page161.
Chinnavatume     pariyadinnavatte     sabbadukkhavitivatte     pannapayamano
pannapeyyati  1-  attheva  suttantoti  .  amanta  .  tena  hi  na
vattabbam atitam atthiti.
     [386]   Atitam  atthiti  .  amanta  .  nanu  ayasma  nandako
etadavoca   ahu   pubbe   lobho   tadahu   akusalam  so  etarahi  natthi
iccetam   kusalam   ahu  pubbe  doso  .pe.  ahu  pubbe  moho  tadahu
akusalam  so  etarahi  natthi  iccetam  kusalanti  2-  attheva suttantoti.
Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam atitam atthiti.
     [387]   Na   vattabbam   anagatam   atthiti  .  amanta  .  nanu
vuttam   bhagavata  kabalikare  ce  bhikkhave  ahare  atthi  rago  atthi
nandi    atthi    tanha    patitthitam    tattha   vinnanam   virulham   yattha
patitthitam   vinnanam   virulham   atthi   tattha   namarupassa  avakkanti  yattha
atthi   namarupassa   avakkanti   atthi   tattha   sankharanam   vuddhi  yattha
atthi    sankharanam    vuddhi   atthi   tattha   ayatim   punabbhavabhinibbatti
yattha    atthi    ayatim    punabbhavabhinibbatti    atthi    tattha   ayatim
jatijaramaranam     yattha    atthi    ayatim    jatijaramaranam    sasokantam
bhikkhave sarajam saupayasanti vadami
     {387.1}  phasse  ce  bhikkhave  ahare  ...  manosancetanaya
ce  bhikkhave  ahare  ...  vinnane ce bhikkhave ahare atthi rago
atthi  nandi  .pe.  sarajam  saupayasanti vadamiti 3- attheva suttantoti.
@Footnote: 1 sam. salayatana. 65. 2 am. tika. 253. 3 sam. ni. 122.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
page162.
Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam anagatam atthiti.
     [388]   Anagatam   atthiti  .  amanta  .  nanu  vuttam  bhagavata
kabalikare   ce   bhikkhave   ahare  natthi  rago  natthi  nandi  natthi
tanha    appatitthitam    tattha    vinnanam   avirulham   yattha   appatitthitam
vinnanam   avirulham   natthi   tattha   namarupassa   avakkanti   yattha  natthi
namarupassa   avakkanti   natthi   tattha   sankharanam   vuddhi   yattha  natthi
sankharanam    vuddhi    natthi   tattha   ayatim   punabbhavabhinibbatti   yattha
natthi   ayatim   punabbhavabhinibbatti   natthi   tattha   ayatim  jatijaramaranam
yattha  natthi  ayatim  jatijaramaranam  asokantam  bhikkhave  arajam anupayasanti
vadami   phasse   ce   bhikkhave   ahare  ...  manosancetanaya  ce
bhikkhave  ahare  ...  vinnane  ce  bhikkhave  ahare  natthi rago
natthi  nandi  .pe.  arajam  anupayasanti vadamiti 1- attheva suttantoti.
Amanta. Tena hi na vattabbam anagatam atthiti.
                      Sabbamatthitikatha.
                             -------


             The Pali Tipitaka in Roman Character Volume 37 page 133-162.
https://84000.org/tipitaka/read/roman_read.php?B=37&A=2692&modeTY=2&pagebreak=1
             Compare with The Pali Tipitaka in Thai Character :-
https://84000.org/tipitaka/read/pali_read.php?B=37&A=2692&modeTY=2&pagebreak=1
             Compare with The Royal Version of Thai Tipitaka :-
https://84000.org/tipitaka/read/byitem.php?book=37&item=301&items=88
             Compare with The MCU Version of Thai Tipitaka :-
https://84000.org/tipitaka/pitaka_item/m_siri.php?B=37&siri=25
             Study Atthakatha :-
https://84000.org/tipitaka/attha/attha.php?b=37&i=301
             The Pali Atthakatha in Thai :-
https://84000.org/tipitaka/atthapali/read_th.php?B=55&A=3804
             The Pali Atthakatha in Roman :-
https://84000.org/tipitaka/atthapali/read_rm.php?B=55&A=3804
             Contents of The Tipitaka Volume 37
https://84000.org/tipitaka/read/?index_37
https://84000.org/tipitaka/english/?index_37